Andrés Paniagua Curiel (anselmo_b) wrote,
Andrés Paniagua Curiel

Some things are not meant to shine and don’t belong in private hands, an obituary for nuclear power

It is very probable that nuclear power will be banished from Germany in the short term. There is a long tradition of opposition to it. With large portions of the population rejecting atomic energy, a whole political movement grew out of the culture of anti-nuclear protests that is now a major player in German politics. The recent events in Japan caught the government with its pants down: The current administration had recently reverted laws of a previous Green and Social Democrat coalition, and legislated a delay in the shutdown and abandonment of nuclear plants as power sources, dismissing any protestations of risks to the population and the environment, even from the older ones. This was perceived by many as a sell out the powerful energy industry by an administration with a bad reputation of catering to the private sector. Then, practically within hours of the catastrophe in Fukujima, the government again reversed its policy, ordering the temporary shutdown of several nuclear plants and declaring that the enormous risks of the technology needed to be carefully reassessed. This manoeuvre caused it to be perceived by the majority of the population as a gang of opportunistic power greedy scoundrels who’d been lying about the risks for decades. Nuclear power in any form whatsoever is politically dead in Germany, and will remain so for a very long time.
Everything I’ve said so far is more or less particular to Germany, but there is a factor that makes it very probable that the history of nuclear power will develop in a similar way all over the world:
Nuclear energy production as we know it is not safe.
The reasons for this are simple; immediately after its development, nuclear technology became an object of national prestige and private profit, two things that don’t mix well with public interests such as safety or environmental soundness. As long as there is an extra dollar to be made, it is going to be made. No matter what the cost to society. By now we know that what happened in Japan was not caused by the earthquake. The earthquake was the trigger of the catastrophe, but its causes lie in the greed for profit of the company that ran the plants and illegally saved on maintenance and safety procedures.
I am not against nuclear energy. I’ve never been to a protest march, anti-nuclear politics don’t appeal to me. But I know that what we have is not what we need; it neither is safe, nor does it have a future. I wish nuclear technology did have a future. I wish its development had been pursued in the last sixty years with the same zeal as in the beginning. I wish it had been taken to the stage of becoming a safe and clean unlimited source of energy as it once promised to be. I wish it had been kept in the hands of the state, a state more concerned with the upkeep of its citizens’ interests than with beating the other side, facilitating the profit making of the private sector, or increasing the prestige of its leaders and its ideology.
It might be too late for nuclear energy, but humanity still is going to have to make the same considerations with regard to its alternatives, because even if they can’t blow up in our faces in the same deathly way, they also won’t serve to solve our problems if we deal with them in the same stupid manner. Just think of the already ongoing madness of human beings starving while others drive around in food fuelled cars feeling blissful about their contribution to the saving of the planet.

  • Hmmmm.

    I always have a tab opened to my LJ friends page. For some reason it was set to my own journal in the past few weeks and I didn't realise it. So…

  • Delivery

    Delivery Ahead of you, still shut, the passageway Into noise, strife and time. You realize the rocking has stopped Labours are grinding down To a…

  • Death Fugue

    Death Fugue Black milk of dawn we drink it at evening we drink it at noontime we drink it at night we drink and we drink we shovel a grave in the…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.